It's Derby Weekend

What’s the Best Bourbon for a Mint Julep? Pro Bartenders Weigh in

May 3, 2019 Drinks By
Purchasing products through our links may earn us a portion of the sale, which supports our editorial team’s mission. Learn more here.

The mint julep has been the official beverage of the Kentucky Derby since 1938, and for most people, Derby weekend will be the only time of the year it’s on the mind. That’s a shame. Because as delicious as they are watching horses run around a track, they’re equally refreshing on a random summer afternoon.

As far as cocktails go, the mint julep is reasonably idiot-proof — simply mix water, sugar, bourbon and mint over crushed ice. It’s also very booze-forward, meaning the bourbon you use determines almost everything about the drink. So, which bottle is best? Five pros weigh in.

Maker’s Mark

“For me, Maker’s Mark is the perfect bourbon to make juleps because of its wheated mash bill, which gives it a natural depth that complements the mint and sugar perfectly. Plus at 90 proof, you can have more than one. Just make sure your mint is fresh and your bourbon supply is rich.” — Kristina Magro, Sportsman’s Club, Chicago, IL

Koval Bourbon

“[Koval] is a brand that, as a Chicagoan, I stand behind — not just because of the quality but because of the people behind the quality. It was the first Chicago distillery to be founded since the 1800’s. The family uses organic processes and ingredients and micromanages the distilling process, showing their passion for quality and a commitment to excellence. Koval translates to ‘black sheep’ which is a perception of others in the industry that they fully embrace.” — Jeff Shull, Baptiste & Bottle, Chicago, IL

Old Forester Single Barrel

“Old Forester is such a workhorse bourbon for the quality and the price, especially the Single Barrel. The rich burnt-sugar character of the bourbon balances really well with the mint and sugar but also has a lot of character for a spirit-forward cocktail. Also, their master distiller is an avid equestrian.” — Jonathan Strader, Hatchet Hall, Los Angeles, CA

Eagle Rare

“I love this bourbon because it’s super affordable but also tastes delicious. Basically, it’s not going to break the bank but tastes like it might.” — Shawn Stanton, Working Class Outlaws, Detroit, MI

Elijah Craig Small Batch

“[Elijah Craig] is the father of bourbon, and it’s very well priced. The sweetness from the corn pairs beautifully with the other ingredients. I prefer to use simple syrup over a sugar cube in my julep. It tends to blend into the bourbon and mint more thoroughly. With lots of finely crushed ice, it’s a refreshing adult snow cone.” — Tracey Eden, American Whiskey, New York, NY

The 17 Best Bourbons You Can Buy in 2019

Everything you ever wanted to know about America’s favorite brown spirit, including, of course, the best bottles you can actually buy. Read the Story

Note: Purchasing products through our links may earn us a portion of the sale, which supports our editorial team’s mission. Learn more here.

Will Price

Will Price is Gear Patrol's home and drinks editor. He's from Atlanta and lives in Brooklyn. He's interested in bourbon, houseplants, cheap Japanese pens, and cast-iron skillets — maybe a little too much.

More by Will Price | Follow on Contact via Email
Sign Up for Gear Patrol Newsletters
Useful product reviews, work-from-home tips
and expert advice in your inbox daily.

By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email correspondence from us.