Fresh Horses

Nike’s Latest Pegasus Is Both Futuristic and Familiar


May 15, 2020 Reviews By Photo by Nick Kova
Purchasing products through our links may earn us a portion of the sale, which supports our editorial team’s mission. Learn more here.
Brand: Nike
Product: Air Zoom Pegasus 37
Release Date: April 28, 2020
Price: $120
From: nike.com

Given the continuous innovation in the modern athletic shoe industry, it’s rare for a given model to stick around for five years, let alone 10, let alone… 37. And yet that is how long Nike has kept the Pegasus nameplate in its stable. Launched in 1983, Pegs sheath the feet of a veritable army of devoted fans. I know this not only because it’s Nike’s all-time bestselling running shoe but because my dad is one of those fans. When he was regularly running marathons, he would buy pairs he liked two at a time, just in case the brand discontinued that particular iteration.

In retrospect, that was a smart strategy for addressing a valid concern, as Nike does update its performance shoes regularly in response to emerging R&D, and the Pegasus is no exception. It’s worth noting that the basic philosophy behind the shoe has not wavered. As the brand itself stated a couple of years ago, the Pegasus was “intended to be the shoe for every runner… designed to be half air (similar to the winged half-horse it was named after) to represent movement, quickness and the allure of flying.”

However, outside of the three years it was not part of Nike’s running shoe line — 1997 to 1999 — the Pegasus has regularly evolved. As recently as 2018, the Pegasus 35 drew inspiration from the Zoom Vaporfly 4%’s full-length carbon plate by featuring a full-length, articulated Zoom airbag. Now the latest version, the Pegasus 37, is the product of a new round of dynamic testing with both male and female runners. That research resulted in two major changes: an airbag more than twice as thick (10mm vs. 4 mm) and concentrated in the forefoot, and a gender-specific midsole, tuned to 20 psi for men and 15 psi for women.

Is the latest evolution of Pegasus the best… and for whom? Our crew of testers laced up some brand-new pairs to find out.

What We Like

One of the first things our testers — some of whom have been trying out the various iterations of Pegasus for years — noticed was a sense of stable comfort.

“I like how supportive and plush they feel from the moment you first step into them,” one commented. “It’s a much thicker and more supportive upper. The tongue is shorter and less flexible to be more supportive. The heel cup seems similar support wise, just a bit more padded.”

Adding to that sentiment, another tester saw a resemblance to Pegs of yore. “The new foam is noticeable,” he noted. “It’s a lot of softer and springier, but less responsive; the last two iterations of the Pegasus felt really quick and fast. I see the 37s as a return to form of sorts for what earlier iterations aspired to be: a no-nonsense running shoe for easy days.”

A third tester thought the shoe’s looks were also worthy of note. “The styling makes me feel like a better runner than I actually am,” he remarked. “I am not typically one to wear running shoes when not running, but I just might wear this pair for non-running activities.”

Watch Out For

The phrase “the shoe for every runner” has a democratizing, middle-of-the-pack feel, but the flip side of that coin is that more ambitious runners might be left wanting.

“I don’t need this much support in running shoes so I’d like to slim down the upper,” said a female tester who has run Boston Marathon-qualifying times. “I prefer a shoe that’s lighter and more flexible. There’s a lot of cushion in this, especially due to the airbag that’s been shortened and is just in the forefoot now. You can feel that padding underfoot as a midfoot striker.”

She also shared a pro tip: “when you use a heel lock on this it’s extremely supportive, so that’s helpful if you feel like your ankles/lower calves get tired after runs.”

“I will wear these for easy/recovery days,” said another high-performing tester. “I would never take these to the track.”

Other Options

Given its level of cushioning and support, the new Pegasus has drawn comparisons to the Asics Gel-Cumulus and the Saucony Kinvara. That’s not too surprising, as both are hugely popular shoes at the top of their respective brand’s lines.

Verdict

If you’re looking for a shoe that boosts your speed work or helps you hit a new 10K PR, look elsewhere. However, if you’re more of a workhorse runner who appreciates support, cushioning and durability, you’ll likely find a fit here.

“A good overall option for new runners, people who just run a few times a week and/or run the same distance/intensity every time they run,” observed one of our testers. “People who do long runs, tempos and speedwork will still get use here, but they’ll want to supplement with other types of shoes.”

“I would recommend these to a runner who wants to feel their sneakers hug their feet,” another tester concluded. “These are for someone who wants to feel more cushion underfoot rather than feel the ground. If you’re used to running in a stability sneaker (slightly heavier) this is a good transition shoe to help mix up your repertoire.”

Bottom line: as a streamlined step up for stability fiends and a recovery shoe for speed freaks, the Pegasus 37 is true to its roots as a shoe for every runner. Just make sure to be clear about your plans for it before hitting the road.

Nike provided this product for review.

Photos provided by Nick Kova.

The Best New Running Gear for Spring 2020

Running is a wonderful coping mechanism, and these shoes, shades and apparel will help you cope like the wind. Read the Story

Note: Purchasing products through our links may earn us a portion of the sale, which supports our editorial team’s mission. Learn more here.

Steve Mazzucchi

Steve Mazzucchi is Gear Patrol’s outdoors and fitness editor. Outside the office, you can find him mountain biking, snowboarding, motorcycling or sipping a dram of Laphroaig and daydreaming about such things.

More by Steve Mazzucchi | Follow on Facebook · Instagram · Twitter · Contact via Email
Sign Up for the
Daily Dispatch
Useful product reviews, work-from-home tips
and expert advice packed into one handy, daily email.

By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email correspondence from us.