Google Finally Made the Fitness Tracker Apple and Whoop Wouldn’t

For years, big tech has treated wearables with screens as an inevitability.

Every new fitness tracker became a little more like a smartwatch. And every smartwatch became a little more demanding of your regular attention, which, if we’re being honest, has felt like the industry’s true endgame for years.

But now, the pendulum might, just maybe, be swinging back towards its early roots, thanks, in part, to the brand that first made fitness trackers a thing nearly 20 years ago.

Google

Google’s newly announced Fitbit Air is a fully modernized $99 screenless device that strips the hardware side of the fitness and health-tracking equation down to its essentials: health tracking, battery life, and subtle design.

It can’t show texts or emails. It doesn’t mirror notifications. It can’t file your taxes. And these hard nos aren’t design limitations. They’re the biggest selling point.

What it does and doesn’t really owe to Whoop

Gear Patrol Studios

Most coverage will understandably frame the Fitbit Air as a new rival to Whoop due to its similar form factor and purpose. But this take feels myopic on multiple fronts.

Whoop can’t take credit for inventing the dedicated fitness tracker or popularizing it.

The original Fitbit tracker launched in 2009 three years before Whoop was founded. The lightweight tracker was designed as a clip that hooked onto clothing or shoelaces and focused almost entirely on passive data collection, with a tiny LED display capable of little more than showing your daily step count.

Today, the first Fitbit looks almost primitive compared to modern wearables. But the company deserves enormous credit for jumpstarting the product category a full five years before the Apple Watch arrived and transformed fitness tracking into a far more screen-centric experience built around apps, notifications and constant interaction.

Whoop

Fitbit also helped popularize one of the most frustratingly entrenched, misunderstood and parodied aspects of the modern wellness era: the famous 10,000-step goal.

As The Guardian reported years ago, the target itself was less rooted in rigorous medical science than many consumers realized, tracing back largely to a Japanese pedometer marketing campaign from the 1960s. While modern research still strongly supports the benefits of regular movement, the tech industry’s fixation on that exact number – and lack of attention to the role of rest and recovery – has increasingly come under scrutiny.

That combined history would make the Fitbit Air release feel oddly circular, if not for the impact that Whoop has had beyond wearable hardware design.

The plucky tech startup competing under the shadow of global tech titans proved to consumers that devices once dismissed as battery-powered step counters can serve as ultra-advanced health monitors, performance trackers, and coaches when paired with robust software.

And it’s continued, and undeniable success has also proven something else equally important.

After years of being bombarded with ever-larger displays and deeper app ecosystems, a growing number of consumers seem increasingly interested in wearable tech that quietly disappears into the background.

A new era for Fitbit

Google

After spending more than a decade chasing larger displays and honing the Pixel Watch and kid-focused wearables like the Ace, Google now appears to be steering the Fitbit team back toward the hardware philosophy that originally made the brand successful.

That shift feels notable because Fitbit’s future has looked increasingly uncertain since Google acquired the company in 2021.

As legacy Fitbit devices were gradually discontinued and Fitbit’s expertise became more deeply integrated into Google’s broader health and wellness ambitions, many consumers wondered whether the brand itself might slowly fade into the long list of Google acquisitions absorbed into a larger ecosystem.

Instead, the Fitbit Air marks the company’s first major new Fitbit hardware release in roughly four years and potentially a bigger return to form for the brand.

Simple and sleek

Google

The new Fitbit Air is intentionally simple.

It consists of a lightweight, pebble-shaped tracker that easily swaps in and out of various interchangeable band styles, ranging from sportier woven straps to sleeker lifestyle options.

Google says the device is 20 percent lighter than the old Fitbit Luxe, offers up to seven days of battery life and automatically tracks workouts, sleep, heart rate, blood oxygen levels and recovery metrics.

Using the Air doesn’t happen on the device itself for the most part. Instead of interacting directly with the tracker, users primarily engage through the Google Health app.

Google

The standard experience includes core health tracking and wellness insights, while an optional Google Health Premium subscription, which costs $10 a month or $99 a year, can add deeper coaching tools and Gemini-powered AI insights designed to interpret long-term health patterns and habits.

Google is also positioning the app as something larger than a traditional fitness dashboard. Similar to Apple’s own Health platform, the company says users will eventually be able to integrate medical records, lab results and additional wellness data into a more unified health system

As is always the case when Google’s involved with personal data, the company’s increasingly unified health ecosystem could become either a major advantage or a major liability, depending on how consumers respond to deeper AI integration and data sharing concerns.

Far from a true Whoop dupe

Google

Though they may look similar, the Fitbit Air is noticeably smaller than the Whoop 5.0.

Google says the Fitbit Air measures just 1.4 by 0.7 by 0.3 inches and weighs 12 grams with its band attached, while Whoop lists the 5.0 at 34.7 mm by 24 mm by 10.6 mm — roughly 1.37 by 0.94 by 0.42 inches — with a substantially thicker and wider footprint.

That Air’s weekish-long battery life is also half of the quoted 14-day max cited by Whoop.

But the Fitbit Air also enters the market at a dramatically lower price point of $100.

Google

For comparison, Whoop’s business model doesn’t sell trackers to consumers outright. Instead, users purchase annual subscriptions that include the wearable alongside access to the companion app. And the entry-level Whoop option costs $199 for 12 months of use.

Based on the dashboard and press information available about the Air so far, Fitbit doesn’t appear to be chasing the same hyper-optimized audience obsessed with strain scores, longevity metrics and recovery-maxing as the Whoop either.

Back to the future?

Google

Scroll through Reddit discussions about why users gravitate toward Whoop or threads filled with watch enthusiasts embracing screenless trackers, and a recurring theme quickly emerges. Many people still want robust health data, but no longer want a smartwatch dominating their wrist or attention span.

It’s an opening in the wearable market that Apple, despite its continued dominance in smartwatches, has shown surprisingly little interest in pursuing. At the same time, Whoop has remained laser-focused on securing the respect of a more intense and demanding subsegment.

The Fitbit Air may not threaten Whoop’s hold on serious athletes just yet, especially given the latter’s deeper recovery ecosystem and coaching tools. Nor is it likely to convince masses of entrenched Apple Watch users to suddenly abandon their ecosystem.

But the device also doesn’t need to do either to become important.

Google

In the 17 years since Fitbit kicked off the wearable race, the industry has largely split into two directions, and the Fitbit Air feels like one of the first major reboots in years to seriously target the enormous middle ground sitting between those extremes.

The new Fitbit Air suggests Google has finally reassessed what made Fitbit compelling in the first place. Not as another screen competing for your attention, but as a simple piece of hardware quietly helping normalize the idea that everyday health data could be useful at scale.

Only now, the sensors, software and health ecosystem behind that original idea are dramatically more powerful than they were the first time around.

Availability and pricing

The Fitbit Air is available for preorder now, starting at $100, and includes a three-month trial of Google Health Premium.

The Stephen Curry special edition version costs $130.

Google says the Fitbit Air officially launches on May 26, while the new Google Health app begins rolling out on Android and iOS starting May 19.

Google

Google Fitbit Air

• $99 at Google
• $99 at Amazon

Want to stay up to date on the latest product news and releases? Add Gear Patrol as a preferred source to ensure our independent journalism makes it to the top of your Google search results.

Related Topics